The gap theory: the war that took place between Genesis 1:1 and Genesis 1:2 - DeepDive Podcast

Erik H. Jansen

Listen to the DeepDive Podcast above.
Nederlandse lezers:

De Gap-theorie: de oorlog die plaatsvond tussen Genesis 1:1 en Genesis 1:2 - DeepDive Podcast

The opening verses of the Bible, Genesis 1:1-2, form one of the most iconic and profound passages in Scripture:

“In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth. The earth was without form and void, and darkness was over the face of the deep. And the Spirit of God was hovering over the waters.”

These words paint a picture of a majestic creation, followed by an intriguing description of an earth that is “without form and void,” shrouded in darkness. For many readers, these verses raise questions: What happened between the creation of the heavens and the earth and the chaotic state of the earth? Was there a gap, a hidden history, that the Bible does not explicitly mention? An intriguing theological interpretation, often referred to as the “gap theory” or “restoration theory,” suggests that a cosmic rebellion—a heavenly conflict—occurred between Genesis 1:1 and 1:2, plunging the original creation into chaos. The theory has both proponents and opponents. My interest lies in the arguments of its supporters: therefore, this article explores this alternative theological perspective, its potential implications for our understanding of Scripture, and the broader cosmic context of God’s creative work.

The context of Genesis 1:1-2

To investigate the possibility of a cosmic rebellion, we must first carefully examine the text of Genesis 1:1-2. In verse 1, the creation of the heavens and the earth is described as an act of God, without further details about the process or timeframe. This verse presents God as the sovereign Creator, who with infinite power and wisdom brings the universe into existence. However, verse 2 introduces an unexpected twist: the earth is “without form and void” (tohu wa-bohu in Hebrew), a term that in other biblical contexts (such as Isaiah 34:11 and Jeremiah 4:23) implies chaos, disorder, or judgment. Furthermore, there is “darkness over the face of the deep,” and the Spirit of God is hovering over the waters, suggesting preparation for restoration or reconstruction.

The Hebrew expression tohu wa-bohu deserves closer attention. The word tohu implies emptiness, formlessness, or futility, while bohu intensifies this sense of chaos, often associated with a desolate or ruined state. In Isaiah 45:18, it is explicitly stated that God did not create the earth “without form” (tohu), but to be inhabited. This contrast between Genesis 1:1 and 1:2 fuels the question of why the earth is in a chaotic state, which seems inconsistent with an originally perfect creation by an almighty God. Moreover, the mention of “darkness” (choshek) and the “deep” (tehom) suggests an atmosphere of disorder, possibly even a context of judgment, as darkness in Scripture often symbolizes divine disapproval or separation from God’s light (cf. Exodus 10:21-22).

Some theologians and biblical scholars argue that this description of a chaotic earth does not align with the expectation of a perfect creation. This has led to the hypothesis that an event occurred between the creation (verse 1) and the chaos (verse 2) that disrupted the original order. A popular speculation within certain Christian circles is that this disruption was the result of a cosmic rebellion, led by a fallen heavenly entity, often identified as Satan or “the dragon” in apocalyptic literature. This rebellion would have transformed the earth from an originally ordered state into the chaos described in Genesis 1:2.

A cosmic rebellion

The notion of a cosmic rebellion finds its origins in a combination of biblical passages, apocryphal writings, and theological interpretations. While the Bible does not provide an explicit description of a pre-Adamite rebellion, several texts offer points of connection for this theory.

Satan as the fallen angel

In passages such as Isaiah 14:12-15 and Ezekiel 28:12-17, a figure—often interpreted as Satan—is described as rising against God in pride and being cast out of heaven. Isaiah speaks of the “morning star” (helel ben shachar, translated as Lucifer in the Vulgate), who “fell from heaven” due to his desire to be “like the Most High.” Ezekiel describes a “cherub” who was perfect until iniquity was found in him and who was expelled from God’s presence due to his rebellion. Although these passages primarily address earthly kings (the king of Babylon and Tyre), many theologians see a dual meaning, pointing to a heavenly figure who rebelled against God.

If we place this rebellion in the context of Genesis 1:1-2, one might speculate that this uprising had a devastating impact on the physical creation. The term tohu wa-bohu in Genesis 1:2 could be seen as a consequence of divine judgment on this rebellion, whereby the earth was brought into a state of chaos. This idea is reinforced by the fact that God, in subsequent verses, restores and orders the creation, culminating in the creation of humanity as the crown of His work. The presence of the Spirit of God “hovering” (rachaph, a term implying movement and care) over the waters suggests a divine intention to restore order to a fallen creation, further supporting the gap theory.

A pre-Adamite world

Some theologians go further and suggest that the original creation in Genesis 1:1 included a pre-Adamite world, populated by other beings or civilizations. This speculation is often fueled by apocryphal texts, such as the Book of Enoch, which speaks of fallen angels exerting influence on the earth before the flood. Although these texts are not canonical, they provide a lens through which some Christians interpret a broader cosmic history. For example, 1 Enoch 6-8 describes the fall of angels who corrupted the earth, which some believers connect to a pre-Adamite chaos.

In this view, the rebellion of a heavenly prince, supported by a host of fallen angels (cf. Revelation 12:4, where “a third of the stars” are swept down with the dragon), would have led to a conflict that disrupted not only the heavenly order but also the physical world. Some thinkers suggest that the chaotic state of the earth in Genesis 1:2 reflects a divine judgment, similar to the later flood, whereby God cleansed the earth of corruption. This idea finds some support in 2 Peter 3:5-6, which speaks of an earth that was “formed out of water” and later judged by water, interpreted by some scholars as referring to both a pre-Adamite chaos and the flood.

Cosmic traces of conflict

A speculative but fascinating addition to the gap theory is the suggestion that other celestial bodies in our solar system bear traces of this cosmic rebellion. The craters on the moon, the barren landscapes of Mars, or the extreme conditions of other planets are sometimes interpreted as remnants of a universal conflict. While the Bible is silent on this matter, the notion of a creation that “groans and suffers in labor pains” (Romans 8:22) provides room for speculation that the consequences of the rebellion extend beyond the earth alone. An intriguing hypothesis within this context is that the asteroid belt between Mars and Jupiter constitutes the remnants of a destroyed planet, sometimes referred to as Rahab in certain interpretations of biblical passages.

The term Rahab appears in Scripture as a symbolic name for chaos or a vanquished enemy, often associated with a mythical sea monster or dragon (cf. Job 9:13, Job 26:12, Psalm 89:11, Isaiah 51:9-10). In these verses, Rahab is described as an entity that is “crushed” (machatz), “cut down” (chatzab), or “pierced” (chalal), indicating a powerful, destructive act. Some theologians speculate that Rahab is not merely a symbol of chaos but may refer to a celestial body that was destroyed through divine judgment as a result of the cosmic rebellion. For instance, in Isaiah 51:9, Rahab is mentioned alongside a “sea dragon” (tannin), which, in a cosmic reading, could point to a planet that was shattered, with the asteroid belt as the remnant of this catastrophe. The “helpers of Rahab” (Job 9:13) and “Your enemies” (Psalm 89:11) could refer to fallen angels who participated in the rebellion, as suggested in Revelation 12:4.

This interpretation finds some resonance in parallels with chaos monsters such as Leviathan or the Babylonian Tiamat, which in ancient myths represent chaotic forces overcome by a divine power. In the context of the gap theory, the destruction of Rahab could be seen as a divine judgment that caused the chaos of Genesis 1:2, with the “deep” (tehom) possibly reflecting a cosmic chaos. Although this hypothesis is speculative and not explicitly supported by the Bible, it offers an intriguing perspective on how a pre-Adamite rebellion may have left physical traces in our solar system. Scientifically, the asteroid belt is often regarded as material that never formed a planet, but the gap theory allows for an alternative view in which these fragments testify to a cosmic conflict that disrupted the original creation.

The role of advanced technology

An intriguing aspect of some modern interpretations is the suggestion that the cosmic rebellion involved advanced technology. This idea is derived from descriptions of heavenly beings in Scripture, such as the “chariots of fire” in Ezekiel 1, the “wheels within wheels” suggesting complex movements, or the apocalyptic imagery in Revelation, where heavenly entities are described with great power. Some believers posit that fallen angels possessed knowledge or resources surpassing human technology, possibly even capable of influencing or destroying worlds.

This idea aligns with contemporary discussions about the origin of the universe and the possibility of extraterrestrial life. While the Bible makes no direct statements about extraterrestrial technology, some Christians interpret the “spiritual forces in the heavenly realms” (Ephesians 6:12) as entities with capabilities beyond human imagination. In this context, the chaos of Genesis 1:2 could be seen as the result of a destructive application of such forces, possibly as part of a rebellion against God’s order.

Historical development of the gap theory

The gap theory is not a recent invention but has roots in the early church and was later formalized in the 19th and 20th centuries. Early church fathers such as Origen and Augustine speculated about the possibility of a pre-Adamite world, though their ideas were often more philosophical than exegetical. In modern times, the theory was popularized by theologians such as Thomas Chalmers in the 19th century, who sought to reconcile the Bible with emerging geological discoveries pointing to a very old earth. The publication of the Scofield Reference Bible in 1917 played a crucial role in spreading the gap theory among evangelical Christians, suggesting that Genesis 1:2 reflects a judgment following an earlier creation.

Although the theory remains controversial, it provides a framework for integrating biblical and scientific perspectives, particularly in discussions about the age of the earth and the origin of fossils. For proponents of the gap theory, the pre-Adamite chaos may explain the presence of fossils that appear older than human history, without relying solely on the flood as an explanation.

Theological implications

The hypothesis of a cosmic rebellion between Genesis 1:1 and 1:2 has several implications for our understanding of God’s creation and the nature of evil:

• God’s sovereignty
  If a rebellion took place, Scripture emphasizes that God remains sovereign over His creation. The chaos in Genesis 1:2 is followed by God’s restorative work, through which He creates order out of disorder. This underscores the power and authority of God over both heavenly and earthly domains. The movement of the Spirit over the waters symbolizes God’s intention to restore His creation, regardless of the extent of the chaos.

• The origin of evil

  The rebellion of a heavenly prince provides an explanation for the presence of evil before the fall of humanity. It suggests that evil does not begin with Adam and Eve but is rooted in an earlier rebellion against God’s authority. This perspective enriches our understanding of the spiritual battle that runs throughout Scripture, from Genesis to Revelation.

• The human calling

  If the earth was in chaos as a result of a cosmic conflict, the creation of humanity takes on deeper significance. Humanity is not only created to rule over a perfect earth (Genesis 1:28) but also to participate in God’s plan to restore order and justice to a fallen creation. This connects the gap theory to the broader calling of humanity as the image of God, reflecting righteousness and holiness.

• Eschatological hope

  The cosmic rebellion points forward to a future confrontation, as described in Revelation 12 and 20, where the dragon and his followers are ultimately defeated. This connects Genesis 1:1-2 to the larger narrative of redemption and restoration, in which God makes all things new (Revelation 21:5). The gap theory emphasizes that the chaos of the beginning is not a lasting victory for evil but a temporary disruption that God overcomes.

• The scope of creation

  The gap theory also opens the door to speculation about the scope of God’s creation. If Genesis 1:1 encompasses an original creation that extends beyond the earth, it suggests that God’s plan has cosmic dimensions that transcend human history. This perspective can inspire believers to reflect on the grandeur of God’s work, even beyond the boundaries of our planet.

Critical reflection and faith perspective

The speculation about a cosmic rebellion between Genesis 1:1 and 1:2 offers an intriguing lens through which to interpret the opening verses of the Bible. It posits that a heavenly conflict, led by a fallen angel, plunged the original creation into chaos, explaining the “without form and void” state of the earth. This theory combines biblical and apocryphal elements to sketch a broader cosmic narrative in which humanity plays a central role in God’s plan for restoration. While the gap theory is not accepted by all Christians, it provides a framework for exploring complex questions about the age of the earth, the origin of evil, and the cosmic dimensions of God’s creation.

For believers, this reflection offers an opportunity to contemplate the depth of God’s creation, the reality of spiritual warfare, and the hope of ultimate redemption. Whether one accepts the gap theory or not, Genesis 1:1-2 remains a powerful invitation to marvel at the majesty of God, who transforms chaos into order and brings light into darkness. May this contemplation inspire us to take our calling as stewards of God’s creation seriously, in anticipation of the day when all things will be made new.

Between the Beginning and the Void

(Intro)
In the dawn of time, God’s voice did soar,
Created heavens, earth, and all before.
A perfect world, His glory to unfold,
Yet shadows stirred, a tale yet untold.

(Verse 1)
A morning star, in pride he fell,
With rebel hosts, he dared to dwell.
The earth grew formless, lost in night,
Yet God’s own hand would set it right.

(Chorus)
Between the beginning and the void,
A cosmic war, His peace destroyed.
From chaos deep, His Spirit calls,
Restoring light where darkness falls.

(Verse 2)
Man formed in dust, Your image true,
To rule, restore, and make all new.
From ancient strife to victory’s day,
Your kingdom comes, Your will to stay.

(Chorus)
Between the beginning and the void,
A cosmic war, His peace destroyed.
From chaos deep, His Spirit calls,
Restoring light where darkness falls.

(Bridge)
O sovereign Lord, Your will prevails,
Through broken worlds, Your love unveils.
From tohu’s waste, Your voice resounds,
New life, new hope, Your grace abounds.

(Chorus)
Between the beginning and the void,
A cosmic war, His peace destroyed.
From chaos deep, His Spirit calls,
Restoring light where darkness falls.

(Outro)
O God of light, Your plan endures,
Through rebel’s fall, Your truth is sure.
From Genesis to heaven’s throne,
All things are Yours, and Yours alone.

#GapTheory

#CosmicRebellion

#Genesis1

#CreationStory

#SpiritualWarfare